Lois Lowry
Lois Lowry
Lois Lowry
Lois Lowry
Lois Lowry
Lois Lowry
Lois Lowry
Lois Lowry
Lois Lowry
Dear Lois Lowry,
See, I'm hoping you'll google yourself, Ms. Lowry. I really am. Why? Because I feel I need to get a message to you.
I just finished reading your most recent book, Messenger. It was really not that great, but I feel like you know that already. The book had the aura of "not trying too hard" about it to begin with, and the loose ends you left could be knit into a sizeable sweater. For example: what happened to Trademaster at the end? Why did Kira have to come home if the forest could be healed by Matty in the first place? What's the deal with the relationship between the societies of The Giver and Gathering Blue? Why Jonas' old home send him all the books?
I could go on.
Before I give you my message, I'm going to quote your book for you. Maybe, upon reading it again, you'll see the problem:
"Do you know," he went on, "in the place where I was a child, there were no dogs? No animals at all."
"No chickens? Or goats?"
"No, nothing."
"What did you eat, then?" Matty asked.
"We had fish. Lots of fish, from a hatchery. And plenty of vegetables. But no animal meat."
Ms. Lowry. Really. You have won at least two Newberry Awards. And you don't know that fish are animals? They are animals! Google it! Look it up on freaking Wikipedia! They are not swimming vegetables!
For reals, Ms. Lowry. Get with the program. If you don't believe me, or Wikipedia, or the Encyclopedia Britanica, or whatever, then I suggest you test my assertion for yourself. Go out and try to catch a carrot. See how difficult it is? Did it try to escape? Flop around in pain after being pulled from the ground? Did it have eyeballs, and guts that needed to be "cleaned" out? NO. Now go try and catch a fish, and note the difference. OK?
Thank you for your time.
Sincerely,
the vegan vulcan







